View from the fence

Social, environmental and economic issues surrounding GM foods, and the latest news

GM is a distraction

4 Comments

This week I went to a debate at the British Library about ‘Biotech on the Farm’. A geneticist, an economist and a Friends of the Earth campaigner talked genetic modification, taxes and eating meat as part of the regular TalkScience series. There was far more which the panel agreed on than might have been anticipated, driven by the common understanding that we need to increase food production while protecting the environment.

The geneticist and Friends of the Earth campaigner found plenty of common ground, and plenty to disagree on. They both believe genetic modification is a distraction. Professor Sang believes the method of production is just a distraction – it’s the product that counts. She was keen to see regulations changed from process-based to product-based: if you produce a herbicide-resistant crop it should be assessed for safety in the same way regardless of how you produce it.

Vicki Hird from Friends of the Earth believed that GM is distracting us from the political issues preventing the distribution of the food we already produce.

I agree that GM and other options for increasing yield can be a distraction from tackling other causes of food insecurity, such as social inequality or logistical challenges. The people who seem distracted by GM are those who campaign against it. Around the world people are still going hungry; I wish those who put effort into convincing us that we only have a distribution and not a production problem would put their effort into tackling this distribution problem and not fighting against alternative solutions.

Other than some strange claims about golden rice (specifically that farmers didn’t want to grow it because Syngenta owned the patent), Vicki Hird from Friends of the Earth had some sound points to make. She only said one majorly annoying thing – she started by suggesting that she would annoy the audience by speaking about the political barriers to effective distribution of the surplus that agriculture currently produces. I begrudge the assumption that because I’m a scientist I’m not interested in political (and social) ways to increase food security. I really am.

Although she was dismissive of all current GM crops, she wasn’t closed to the idea that they could be beneficial in the future. It will be fascinating too see how many of the different communities of environmentalists become open to the possibility for using GMOs.

 

Advertisements

Author: Rebecca Nesbit

I studied for my PhD with the University of York and spent my time chasing migrant butterflies. I have trained bees to detect explosives, written a novel, organised Biology Week for the Society of Biology and visited universities round the world with Nobel Laureates. I am collecting friends to help me save the world. My website is: http://rebeccanesbit.com/

4 thoughts on “GM is a distraction

  1. People that think scientifically can’t help but realize the truth about the technology. If it was discovered today in the public sector and there were no companies involved, people would be embracing this stuff and using it to engineer better tomatoes for organic production– no questions asked!

    • It’s so interesting to think how the history of the debate has influenced how people think about it now.

      People never worry about mutagenesis techniques in conventional breeding, for example, even though they have the same ‘science fiction’ sound to them which could scare off those in the ‘all natural’ camp.

  2. Pingback: Difficult green choices: our diet and our pets | View from the fence

  3. Conventional Breeding would be the best but given the speed at which the results are availed to farmers yet we know we can soberly approach Biotechnological very nicely to get ourselves off the hunger, why should we worry.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s